The Great Replacement

[SwordOfStZip]

A joke

I don't necessarily trust that pair- they seem to get ideas and than just juggle for figures and mush up facts in order to bamboozle themselves that they reflect reality. However I am sure that the issue they raise there is an increasing one.

 

[Myles O'Reilly]

A country in which Muslim gangs have for decades sexually enslaved and tortured hundreds of thousands of native schoolgirls with carte blanche from local government, social services, and the police, the Crown Prosecution Service, and the media, and continue to do so.

According to a certain (female!) Moderator on here this never happened

 

[Neptune]

Moving along, Camus confirming that his "Great Replacement" is not a theory, conspiracy or otherwise, it's a fact


View: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=IIiVPc3FwA8&t=7m17s

A theory explains a fact

 

[AN2]

View: https://t.me/demacre/28090

 

[Uncle Jarlath]

A theory explains a fact

A theory selects and corrals a set of facts, and names this set of facts as a theory (usually).

A good theory is open to facts. If any facts that the theory ought to encompass come along and don't fit very well with the theory, or the theory does not account very well for these newly discerned facts, then the theory is discounted.

A bad theory, also called dogma (and conspiracy theory is basically one variety of dogma), is always careful to exclude facts that do not corroborate the theory.

The dogmatic attitude typically adopts a variety of devices to "fend off" any of these "undesirable facts".

For example, insisting your theory is a fact would be one such device. I.e. The theory is not open to any of the testing or challenge that a theory would normally invite.

 

[Uncle Jarlath]

A theory selects and corrals a set of facts, and names this set of facts as a theory (usually).

The theory normally claims to be an explanation for this set of facts.

 

[Uncle Jarlath]

Did you see this chap is also an illegal immigrant who is going to chuck us all into slurry, and once we're dead, then "replace" us, presumably with his own relatives, who by all accounts have deep suntans.

Michael Gaine murder suspect now accepts remains are those of missing farmer

American Mr Kelley previously falsely accused his ex-wife of 'witchcraft'

www.corkbeo.ie

 

[AN2]

View: https://t.me/realwelshnationalist/19891

 

[SwordOfStZip]

Most Irish believe “The Conspiracy” — official report!

https://c7.alamy.com/comp/T062FG/st-patricks-day-and-africans-emigrants-refugees-take-part-in-the-annual-st-patricks-day-parade-festival-and-celebrations-as-asylum-seekers-immigrants-ireland-concept-T062FG.jpg The Irish Electoral Commission asked people if they agreed with the statement that a...

www.unz.com

".......Scientists are not popular either: Only half disagree that “Groups of scientists manipulate, fabricate or suppress evidence in order to deceive the public.”

In the election we apparently voted 90% + for pro-immigration parties, but this poll shows 73% think “There should be very strict limits on the number of immigrants coming to live in Ireland.”

There is even massive support for the Great Replacement Theory.

“Elected officials want more immigration to bring in obedient voters who will vote for them.” 19% agree, 18% are “not sure”.

“The establishment is replacing white Irish people with non-white immigrants.” 19% agree, 16% are “not sure”....."

 

[AN2]

Most Irish believe “The Conspiracy” — official report!

https://c7.alamy.com/comp/T062FG/st-patricks-day-and-africans-emigrants-refugees-take-part-in-the-annual-st-patricks-day-parade-festival-and-celebrations-as-asylum-seekers-immigrants-ireland-concept-T062FG.jpg The Irish Electoral Commission asked people if they agreed with the statement that a...

www.unz.com

".......Scientists are not popular either: Only half disagree that “Groups of scientists manipulate, fabricate or suppress evidence in order to deceive the public.”

In the election we apparently voted 90% + for pro-immigration parties, but this poll shows 73% think “There should be very strict limits on the number of immigrants coming to live in Ireland.”

That's what I was getting at here:

Post in thread 'Mass immigration accelerating in Italy under Giorgia Meloni and Matteo Salvini' https://www.sarsfieldsvirtualpub.co...ia-meloni-and-matteo-salvini.1245/post-134020

There is even massive support for the Great Replacement Theory.

“Elected officials want more immigration to bring in obedient voters who will vote for them.” 19% agree, 18% are “not sure”.

“The establishment is replacing white Irish people with non-white immigrants.” 19% agree, 16% are “not sure”....."

The article does actually address the great replacement theory, which is actually a conspiracy theory

 

[nobody knows I'm a dog]

"Half of them are prepared to tell the nice man from the polling company that they think the Jews run the world."
Wow!

 

[Uncle Jarlath]

Either "Replacement" or "Great Replacement" is the posited explanation for a set of observed facts, and conjectured facts (counterfactuals).

For example observed facts encompassed by the (plain) theory:

a. Visibly changing demographics particularly observable in some small towns, parts of cities, the staff of hospitals, nursing homes, and a raft of lower paid places of employment that pay insufficiently for those who had their expectations raised during the so called "celtic tiger".

b. Changing policies of immigration, driven by factors including the ponzi element in our economy , and particularly by the problem of the reduction in the ratio between the population in working-age group 15-64 years and the population 65 years or older, or the potential support ratio (PSR). I.e. Not enough working-age population to support the needs of the older retired population.

c. Photos on social media of refugees traveling to Europe, fleeing war, and so on.

So all these kinds of facts, many of which are observed through the lens of social media, and also the many counterfactuals also driven through social media, encompassing hypotheticals, and wished for scenarios, and idealised pasts, and futures, demand some kind of encompassing explanation.

So you have "replacement" which suggests a dynamic that puts people, particularly proponents of the theory, in a central relationship to these facts and counterfactuals, the theory includes them, in fact it positions them as the victim of these observed and non observed facts.

Now you also have "great replacement", which is a variation on the theory - the addition of "great" suggesting conscious willful agency behind the "replacement".

And it is this variation that prompts people to say well then, it is a conspiracy theory.

But actually there are variations on the central theory, that explain the observed facts (from certain perspectives) and the counterfactuals (again strongly driven by personal perspective), by this theory claiming that the explanatory dynamic involved should be characterised "replacement" etc.

 

[Uncle Jarlath]

Most Irish believe “The Conspiracy” — official report!

https://c7.alamy.com/comp/T062FG/st-patricks-day-and-africans-emigrants-refugees-take-part-in-the-annual-st-patricks-day-parade-festival-and-celebrations-as-asylum-seekers-immigrants-ireland-concept-T062FG.jpg The Irish Electoral Commission asked people if they agreed with the statement that a...

www.unz.com

Well you lads are certainly well represented in the little dark green bars at the top (coloured green I expect to indicate this section like to wrap themselves up in the flag to deflect criticism of their ridiculous beliefs).

 

[Uncle Jarlath]

Yes, it's no suprise that most people have those views on immigration.

I kept trying to tell you that you lads are your own worst enemy.

No one is going to vote for the likes of Barrett or that postman dog kicking chap, or the long line of other losers.

And once you guys start opening your traps about "replacement" and "Jews" and "patriots" and all the fucking rest, everyone runs a mile and says anything that comes to mind to dissassociate themselves from you.

 

[PlunkettsGhost]

View: https://x.com/mactre4217421/status/1928070278354989435

 

[AN2]

Either "Replacement" or "Great Replacement" is the posited explanation for a set of observed facts, and conjectured facts (counterfactuals).

For example observed facts encompassed by the (plain) theory:

a. Visibly changing demographics particularly observable in some small towns, parts of cities, the staff of hospitals, nursing homes, and a raft of lower paid places of employment that pay insufficiently for those who had their expectations raised during the so called "celtic tiger".

b. Changing policies of immigration, driven by factors including the ponzi element in our economy , and particularly by the problem of the reduction in the ratio between the population in working-age group 15-64 years and the population 65 years or older, or the potential support ratio (PSR). I.e. Not enough working-age population to support the needs of the older retired population.

c. Photos on social media of refugees traveling to Europe, fleeing war, and so on.

So all these kinds of facts, many of which are observed through the lens of social media, and also the many counterfactuals also driven through social media, encompassing hypotheticals, and wished for scenarios, and idealised pasts, and futures, demand some kind of encompassing explanation.

So you have "replacement" which suggests a dynamic that puts people, particularly proponents of the theory, in a central relationship to these facts and counterfactuals, the theory includes them, in fact it positions them as the victim of these observed and non observed facts.

Now you also have "great replacement", which is a variation on the theory - the addition of "great" suggesting conscious willful agency behind the "replacement".

And it is this variation that prompts people to say well then, it is a conspiracy theory.

But actually there are variations on the central theory, that explain the observed facts (from certain perspectives) and the counterfactuals (again strongly driven by personal perspective), by this theory claiming that the explanatory dynamic involved should be characterised "replacement" etc.

How many times do you have to be told

Replacement*: An observable, empirical fact

Replacement theory: A conspiracy theory that says *replacement is being done on purpose

 

[Uncle Jarlath]

Would you also call it a “great replacement” the aggregate of a son “replacing” his father over a similar timespan? Does it not seem like a silly word to use? Is it not deliberately loaded? If the father was of the easily suggestible type, and told he was being “replaced” by his son, might he not be tempted to carry out a “Titus Andronicus” on his son?

 

[SwordOfStZip]

Would you also call it a “great replacement” the aggregate of a son “replacing” his father over a similar timespan? Does it not seem like a silly word to use? Is it not deliberately loaded? If the father was of the easily suggestible type, and told he was being “replaced” by his son, might he not be tempted to carry out a “Titus Andronicus” on his son?

You should really consider undergoing Freudian analysis.

 

[Aldo]

Well you lads are certainly well represented in the little dark green bars at the top (coloured green I expect to indicate this section like to wrap themselves up in the flag to deflect criticism of their ridiculous beliefs).

It's probably difficult for a bourgeoise trendy gimp in Dublin to gain the perspective of the families out marching in towns and villages swamped by gangs of men from North Africa.

You and your compadres really ought to be chucked into a crocodile enclosure for the benefit of wider society.

 

[Myles O'Reilly]

Did you see this chap?

Fukk you Sham. You're a fraud.

 

[AN2]

Would you also call it a “great replacement” the aggregate of a son “replacing” his father over a similar timespan? Does it not seem like a silly word to use? Is it not deliberately loaded? If the father was of the easily suggestible type, and told he was being “replaced” by his son, might he not be tempted to carry out a “Titus Andronicus” on his son?

You previously wrote:

Now you also have "great replacement", which is a variation on the theory - the addition of "great" suggesting conscious willful agency behind the "replacement".

Which is obvious horseshit

The Great Replacement is the title of a book by a French author, who has repeatedly said that he didn't mean it as a "theory" in any way, shape or form

"Great" could easily refer to something profound(ly transformative), which of course, the Great Replacement is

 

[Uncle Jarlath]

Ah,

"Great" could easily refer to something profound(ly transformative), which of course, the Great Replacement is

Ah, it's the great transformation now.

This carefully observed "fact" seems to have suddenly put on a new garb right in front of your eyes.

 

[AN2]

Ah,

Ah, it's the great transformation now.

This carefully observed "fact" seems to have suddenly put on a new garb right in front of your eyes.

Huh? Wha?

Who's stupider, @Tiger or roc

 

[Tiger]

Huh? Wha?

Who's stupider, @Tiger or roc

Nothing says butt hurt more than James randomly tagging me in discussions I’m not involved in.

How many times have I buried your dignity at this stage? Nine? Ten?

 

[AN2]

The two Soapbox Dunces together

 

[Myles O'Reilly]

The two Soapbox Dunces together

Jarlath is Sham

 

[AN2]

Jarlath is Sham

Uncle Jariath is roc

He hasn't attempted to deny it

My guess is that Uncle Jariath is a wordplay on Uncle Jared, but I could be wrong

He (roc) should just register, unless Dan won't let him in

 

[Myles O'Reilly]

If it is the cuckold from Sandyford Dan sure won't let him in.

Miss Catherine would however.

 

[willows68]

Jarlath is Sham

For shure? p

Uncle Jariath is roc

He hasn't attempted to deny it

My guess is that Uncle Jariath is a wordplay on Uncle Jared, but I could be wrong

He (roc) should just register, unless Dan won't let him in

He doesn't sound like Sham. My old buddy from the Crane.

 

[AN2]

For shure?

Yes, fo sho

He's not trying to hide it, if anything, he's doing the opposite

 

[Uncle Jarlath]

I am a media entrepreneur from Galway. Local media for local people.

 

[SwordOfStZip]

My guess is that Uncle Jariath is a wordplay on Uncle Jared, but I could be wrong

I think it is some obscurish dig at the Shinners as opposed to that.

 

[Myles O'Reilly]

I am a media entrepreneur from Galway. Local media for local people.

Aka Sham

What a d1ckhead

 

[AN2]

View: https://t.me/TraditionalBritainGroup/27955


View: https://t.me/TraditionalBritainGroup/27959

 

[AN2]

View: https://t.me/TraditionalBritainGroup/27955


View: https://t.me/TraditionalBritainGroup/27959

"I'll be long gone", says Reform politician -

 

[AN2]

By Millennial Woes...

Part I

The Great Replacement as a Crime (I. Intro)

The most important issue of the 21st Century

millennialwoes.substack.com

 

[céline]

Immigration by Asians is not a problem... the problem is Jews & their negroid slave trade.

 

[AN2]

By Millennial Woes...

Part I

The Great Replacement as a Crime (I. Intro)

The most important issue of the 21st Century

millennialwoes.substack.com

"As this is an extremely contentious topic, we should begin with definitions.

By “White” I mean “genetically European”, regardless of where the person was born or grew up. This is similar to how, by the term “Black”, I mean “genetically Sub-Saharan African”. Such terms have been made controversial within academia in recent decades, but they are completely understandable to ordinary and honest people.

By “formerly White countries” I mean all countries in Europe as well as those founded by Europeans on land they conquered and settled. The latter (United States, Canada, Australia, New Zealand) were not natively White but the lands were transformed into countries populated and dominated for centuries, by White Europeans. Thus they were known as “White countries”. The classifying of any European country as “White” should not be controversial. Whether Europeans described themselves as “White” in previous centuries is irrelevant.

The Great Replacement is the transformation of these White countries into multiracial, multicultural countries. This transformation is happening at unprecedented scale and speed. Its result will not be a sprinkling of benign diversity, but the White majority diminishing to a minority in every one of these countries."

 

[nobody knows I'm a dog]

Not a bad article for a mainstream newspaper.

Ireland’s Urban Plans strain under immigration surge as UN, EU push labour-driven policies – Roscommon People

Ireland’s urban development is under strain as a wave of immigration, fuelled by lenient asylum policies and economic allure, reshapes County Development Plans for 2022-2028. With 98,700 net migrants in 2024, including 13,651 asylum applications in 2022 and 110,000 Ukrainians arriving by early...

roscommonpeople.ie

 

[AN2]