General Chat in The Marcus Lounge.

[Tiger]

Anyone, anyone...

That's right, ad hom

R u done now?

Yes, I’ve wasted enough minutes on here. Minutes that I won’t get back.

I’ll leave you to your evening shift.

I’ll also leave you with some homework. Before tomorrow morning, try to think of 3 real world activities of note that you engaged in today.

Maybe you visited someone or had a date in court. Anyway, that’s your task, see how you get on with it. I’m sure it will be fascinating.

 

[Declan]

A Herculean Task

 

[AN2]

Yes, I’ve wasted enough minutes on here. Minutes that I won’t get back.

I’ll leave you to your evening shift.

I’ll also leave you with some homework. Before tomorrow morning, try to think of 3 real world activities of note that you engaged in today.

Maybe you visited someone or had a date in court. Anyway, that’s your task, see how you get on with it. I’m sure it will be fascinating.

All our sphere of contact is essentially online

If you think that anything you have impresses me, such as an envelope-licking job, a three bed semi with a mortgage, a wife you don't have sex with and a daughter you're indoctrinating into a religious cult (as you were before her).. then you should think again

I think of you as an idiot, a particularly odious idiot

 

[Tiger]

All our sphere of contact is essentially online

Nope, it certainly isn’t.

If you think that anything you have impresses me, such as an envelope-licking job, a three bed semi with a mortgage, a wife you don't have sex with and a daughter you're indoctrinating into a religious cult (as you were before her).. then you should think again

I think of you as an idiot, a particularly odious idiot

Go for a walk today. Get some vitamin D.

The 4 or 5 people that you engage online with everyday won’t be at your funeral. You don’t want to end up being an ‘Elenor Rigby’.

 

[Myles O'Reilly]

In fairness, he doesn't believe that the Earth is flat (much to the chagrin of Hermit who's always begging him to (because of his religion))

I was actually thinking about that very thing regarding Bocht and Tiger.

What's the reason they don't believe the Science that the World is hundreds of millions of years old yet they do believe it regarding the shape of the Earth?

The answer must be that they've got a book who's contents they've decided to literally believe first and then after that fact decided to try and twist every kind of logic and Science - no matter how far fetched - to corroborate their initial decision, ie, to unquestionably believe what's in that book.

The flat earth doesn't arise in that book therefore they don't need to debunk it and will happily accept the reality on this occasion.

They're like a pair of kids in a Pick N' Mix sweet shop.

 

[AN2]

I was actually thinking about that very thing regarding Bocht and Tiger.

What's the reason they don't believe the Science that the World is hundreds of millions of years old yet they do believe it regarding the shape of the Earth?

Their religion, duh

The answer must be that they've got a book who's contents they've decided to literally believe first and then after that fact decided to try and twist every kind of logic and Science - no matter how far fetched - to corroborate their initial decision, ie, to unquestionably believe what's in that book.

Neither of them do science

I suppose Tiger thinks he's on to something with intelligent design but that's creationist claptrap (not science)

The flat earth doesn't arise in that book therefore they don't need to debunk it and will happily accept the reality on this occasion.

Hermit claims that it's in the Bible but obviously the other two aren't buying it

They're like a pair of kids in a Pick N' Mix sweet shop.

 

[Wolf]

The rats are getting out....

Morning Ireland presenter Mary Wilson becomes latest big name to leave RTÉ

Broadcasting stalwart Mary Wilson is retiring this month, in what will be another blow to RTÉ.

m.independent.ie

 

[clarke-connolly]

The rats are getting out....

Morning Ireland presenter Mary Wilson becomes latest big name to leave RTÉ

Broadcasting stalwart Mary Wilson is retiring this month, in what will be another blow to RTÉ.

m.independent.ie

Sinking Shit-House !

 

[AN2]

I was going to ask you which you think would be easier for a child to distinguish between fantasy and reality, Harry Potter or hell.. but then I thought, why the f*ck would I ask you (my mind just has a natural tendency to think of you as an adult)

Do you believe in hell?

My thesis in the above post which seems to have caused some confusion was..

Is a child more likely to believe (the reality of);

Harry Potter, witchcraft

or

Hell

And do you believe that it's wicked to convince a child that hell is a real place? (I posted some supporting video for that here)

The reason that it occurred to me that @scolairebocht was a bad candidate to ask the question is because he's an adult who believes in hell

 

[Wolf]

Isn't it a bit strange that the only accounts here that continually quote and reply to their own posts are WankTank/Jimmy's?

 

[Tiger]

Isn't it a bit strange that the only accounts here that continually quote and reply to their own posts are WankTank/Jimmy's?

Aye.

Myles seems to be giving Jambo a lot of oxygen these days. The fellow traveller life of two bums, eh?

 

[AN2]

Do you believe in hell?

My thesis in the above post which seems to have caused some confusion was..

Is a child more likely to believe (the reality of);

Harry Potter, witchcraft

or

Hell

And do you believe that it's wicked to convince a child that hell is a real place? (I posted some supporting video for that here)

Here is a victim describing their experience -


View: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=u7OyAnn3S7Y&t=65

Any thoughts?

Should adults be abusing children in this way?

The reason that it occurred to me that @scolairebocht was a bad candidate to ask the question is because he's an adult who believes in hell

 

[Tiger]

Here is a victim describing their experience -


View: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=u7OyAnn3S7Y&t=65

Any thoughts?

Should adults be abusing children in this way?

That’s too much internet for you today James. Go outside and play.

 

[AN2]

That’s too much internet for you today James. Go outside and play.

Do you have any thoughts?

 

[Tiger]

Do you have any thoughts?

On what? Whether your atheistic Dad indoctrinated you with your atheist beliefs?

 

[AN2]

On what? Whether your atheistic Dad indoctrinated you with your atheist beliefs?

No, on the subject

As you've mentioned, I'm from a broken home, so my father wasn't that much of an influence (nor was he an atheist as you imagine atheists to be), I just realised, as a child, that religion was man-invented (and not an accurate prescription for God)

 

[Aldo1]

Isn't it instructive that nobody brings up the subject of religion more on this board than AN2 - an avowed atheist.

Every time I log in he's looking to get a reaction from the same one or two posters- usually by posting videos of the most insufferable "public figure" atheists like Dawkins or (even worse) Ricky Gervais mocking religious people.

It's all very repetitive and immature - not to mention deeply ignorant of the human condition. Do these people get a kick out of insulting and mocking devout elderly ladies who go to church on a Sunday and get great comfort from thinking they'll see their deceased relatives again?

Things have got so bad lately that I've noticed poor auld Myles O'Reilly going down the same path. Is AN2 recruiting him via private messages?

 

[Wolf]

Isn't it instructive that nobody brings up the subject of religion more on this board than AN2 - an avowed atheist.

Every time I log in he's looking to get a reaction from the same one or two posters- usually by posting videos of the most insufferable "public figure" atheists like Dawkins or (even worse) Ricky Gervais mocking religious people.

It's all very repetitive and immature - not to mention deeply ignorant of the human condition. Do these people get a kick out of insulting and mocking devout elderly ladies who go to church on a Sunday and get great comfort from thinking they'll see their deceased relatives again?

Things have got so bad lately that I've noticed poor auld Myles O'Reilly going down the same path. Is AN2 recruiting him via private messages?

jimmy's religion is atheism, he's like one of those dodgy preachers ya see in the USA......but pissed most of the time.

 

[AN2]

Isn't it instructive that nobody brings up the subject of religion more on this board than AN2

R u sure about that?

an avowed atheist.

An avowed atheist, what does that mean?

Every time I log in he's looking to get a reaction from the same one or two posters-

usually by posting videos of the most insufferable "public figure" atheists like Dawkins or (even worse) Ricky Gervais mocking religious people.

Again, r u sure about that?

You have nothing of any interest to say but can you not be an adult and at least make factual statements?

It's all very repetitive and immature - not to mention deeply ignorant of the human condition.

Do these people get a kick out of insulting and mocking devout elderly ladies who go to church on a Sunday and get great comfort from thinking they'll see their deceased relatives again?

lol

Things have got so bad lately that I've noticed poor auld Myles O'Reilly going down the same path. Is AN2 recruiting him via private messages?

This is a bigger indignant, anti-atheist dump you've taken on the site than your usual

 

[AN2]

Isn't it instructive that nobody brings up the subject of religion more on this board than AN2

Btw, I think that's demonstrably wrong enough that I've it made it my new sig

 

[Tiger]

Isn't it instructive that nobody brings up the subject of religion more on this board than AN2 - an avowed atheist.

As a general rule of thumb, James is deeply disturbed by people who think they have a soul.

Every time I log in he's looking to get a reaction from the same one or two posters- usually by posting videos of the most insufferable "public figure" atheists like Dawkins or (even worse) Ricky Gervais mocking religious people.

Yup, nailed it on the head. Always utterly ignorable trite.

It's all very repetitive and immature - not to mention deeply ignorant of the human condition. Do these people get a kick out of insulting and mocking devout elderly ladies who go to church on a Sunday and get great comfort from thinking they'll see their deceased relatives again?

Life has not treated James well, ergo he doesn’t like life and the people that occupy it.

Things have got so bad lately that I've noticed poor auld Myles O'Reilly going down the same path. Is AN2 recruiting him via private messages?

I know it’s laughable.

Imagine the two drunks in their private exchange… “You say this, then I’ll reply with this…”

 

[AN2]

jimmy's religion is atheism, he's like one of those dodgy preachers ya see in the USA......but pissed most of the time.

I don't have a religion, Woof

That's the theistic way of thinking about atheism

 

[AN2]

As a general rule of thumb, James is deeply disturbed by people who think they have a soul.

What's that?

Yup, nailed it on the head. Always utterly ignorable trite.

Life has not treated James well, ergo he doesn’t like life and the people that occupy it.

I know it’s laughable.

Imagine the two drunks in their private exchange… “You say this, then I’ll reply with this…”

 

[Tiger]

What's that?

You can deny that you have a soul all you want, but it’s the very thing in you doing the denying.

 

[AN2]

You can deny that you have a soul all you want, but it’s the very thing in you doing the denying.

I asked you what it is, can you answer?

 

[Tiger]

I asked you what it is

It’s the immaterial part of you that asks that question; your body never wondered about anything.

 

[AN2]

It’s the immaterial part of you that asks that question; your body never wondered about anything.

Worst answer ever

Perhaps stop thinking about (religious) buzzwords such as materialism / materialistic..

 

[Wolf]

A manic street preacher.....

 

[AN2]

A manic street preacher.....

This is a very religious site

Perhaps that's why so many people here fold like a cheap suitcase or throw their toys out of the pram under the slightest bit of scrutiny?

 

[Wolf]

This is a very religious site

Perhaps that's why so many people here fold like a cheap suitcase or throw their toys out of the pram under the slightest bit of scrutiny?

Yes, jimmy, your obsession with religion is well documented.
You post about it religiously.

 

[AN2]

Yes, jimmy, your obsession with religion is well documented.
You post about it religiously.

It really doesn't make much sense for you to say that considering I'm not religious and I don't know that much about it albeit I think I know enough to know that it isn't for me. Like I said, I don't think it's an accurate prescription for God, in fact, I think it's palpably ridiculous to believe in any one religion. Change my mind

 

[Tiger]

Worst answer ever

Perhaps stop thinking about (religious) buzzwords such as materialism / materialistic..

James, clearly you operate on a shallow level of existence. However, you should know that you have a soul, it is the non-material essence of a person. The seat of consciousness, identity, and moral agency.

While the brain supports thoughts and perception, the soul is what makes you uniquely you, something science can observe indirectly but cannot fully explain.

 

[AN2]

James, clearly you operate on a shallow level of existence.

I think I'm more thoughtful than you are

However, you should know that you have a soul, it is the non-material essence of a person.

I told you, no religious buzzwords, please

The seat of consciousness, identity, and moral agency.

I'm confused, I have a soul (even though I don't know it) and I'm an atheist.. So why do you religious people keep on telling us atheists that we can't have moral agency if we're atheists?

While the brain supports thoughts and perception, the soul is what makes you uniquely you, something science can observe indirectly but cannot fully explain.

 

[Tiger]

I think I'm more thoughtful than you are


I told you, no religious buzzwords, please


I'm confused, I have a soul (even though I don't know it) and I'm an atheist.. So why do you religious people keep on telling us atheists that we can't have moral agency if we're atheists?

If the soul is an illusion, then explain why people who are clinically dead, with no measurable brain activity, consistently report vivid and verifiable experiences, as documented in peer-reviewed studies like Pim van Lommel’s Lancet paper on Near Death Experiences or the AWARE study led by Dr. Sam Parnia; without a soul, consciousness simply has no business surviving brain death.

 

[jpc]

The rats are getting out....

Morning Ireland presenter Mary Wilson becomes latest big name to leave RTÉ

Broadcasting stalwart Mary Wilson is retiring this month, in what will be another blow to RTÉ.

m.independent.ie

She's at retirement age and decided that's it goodbye, perhaps?
If you're planning on looking at other opportunities and are content to go.
Why not?

 

[Tiger]

 

[AN2]

If the soul is an illusion, then explain why people who are clinically dead, with no measurable brain activity, consistently report vivid and verifiable experiences, as documented in peer-reviewed studies like Pim van Lommel’s Lancet paper on Near Death Experiences or the AWARE study led by Dr. Sam Parnia; without a soul, consciousness simply has no business surviving brain death.

This appears to be your second attempt at steering the conversation into me denying the existence of a soul

I would be interested in your answer to my last question, to reiterate; You say that I have soul, which is responsible for moral agency but religious people say that atheists don't have that. Did you slip up?

 

[Tiger]

This appears to be your second attempt at steering the conversation into me denying the existence of a soul

I would be interested in your answer to my last question, to reiterate; You say that I have soul, which is responsible for moral agency but religious people say that atheists don't have that. Did you slip up?

Your question was ignored because it’s a silly strawman. Everyone has a soul despite what their believes are. The soul is what makes someone rational, capable of free will and hence, morally responsible for their actions. It’s what the Catholic Church refers to as ‘the natural law’. So, unbelievers can act morally because they participate in reason.

Now, that that’s out of the way….if consciousness is entirely reducible to brain activity, how do you account for rigorously documented death experiences, such as those in the Lancet study by Pim van Lommel; where patients reported accurate perceptions of their surroundings during periods of flatlined EEG and absent cortical activity. In other words, how can veridical conscious experience occur in the total absence of measurable brain function and why is there such commonality in these death experiences regardless of the cultural or religious background of the person who dies?

 

[AN2]

Your question was ignored because it’s a silly strawman.

R u denying that religious people say that atheists don't have moral agency because why would they (atheists)?

Everyone has a soul despite what their believes are. The soul is what makes someone rational, capable of free will and hence, morally responsible for their actions. It’s what the Catholic Church refers to as ‘the natural law’.

So, unbelievers can act morally because they participate in reason.

Is a belieber doing something different and if so, what?

Now, that that’s out of the way….if consciousness is entirely reducible to brain activity, how do you account for rigorously documented death experiences, such as those in the Lancet study by Pim van Lommel; where patients reported accurate perceptions of their surroundings during periods of flatlined EEG and absent cortical activity. In other words, how can veridical conscious experience occur in the total absence of measurable brain function and why is there such commonality in these death experiences regardless of the cultural or religious background of the person who dies?

 

[Tiger]

R u denying that religious people say that atheists don't have moral agency because why would they (atheists)?

See this is why people don’t bother trying to engage with you. You’re worse than a bot. Always dodging everything. Totally disingenuous.

I have explained my position. Asking me about what some of the other 7 billion people on the planet think is moronic.

Is a belieber doing something different and if so, what?

The difference is how moral actions are ordered. Unbelievers may act in accordance with natural law, but without faith and sanctifying grace. They lack the supernatural virtues that order those actions toward eternal beatitude. You won’t like or even understand that answer, but there you go.

Now, that that’s out of the way….if consciousness is entirely reducible to brain activity, how do you account for rigorously documented death experiences, such as those in the Lancet study by Pim van Lommel; where patients reported accurate perceptions of their surroundings during periods of flatlined EEG and absent cortical activity. In other words, how can veridical conscious experience occur in the total absence of measurable brain function and why is there such commonality in these death experiences regardless of the cultural or religious background of the person who dies?

You’re on your final warning. Answer the question or bugger off.